Read the Roper v Simmons 543 U.S. 551 (2005)

then post the following

1. who won - the real name of the person - not plaintiff, etc. -

2. why

3. legal principle

4. legal reasoning or rationale given by the court

Do not brief the case, use your own words, and just 3-4 sentences of explanation each for #3 legal principle and # 4 legal reasoning by the court. Points deducted if you do not follow the above abbreviated format. Who won must be the "actual name" of the party, and NOT "appellant"